V

X

Y

Z

#

A

AIA CES Credits

AV Office

321M Fayerweather Hall

Christopher Day, Kane H. Chiang, Ben Goldie

/audio-video-off…

Abstract Publication

415 Avery Hall

Academic Affairs

400 Avery Hall

Danielle Smoller

/academic-affair…

Academic Calendar, Columbia University

http://registrar…

Academic Calendar, GSAPP

/academic-calend…

Admissions Office

407 Avery Hall
1172 Amsterdam Avenue
New York, New York 10027

Steffen Boddeker, Sara Konekeo, Monisola Fakiyesi

Advanced Standing Waiver Form

Must be printed and returned to 400 Avery Hall

https://d37vpt3x…

Alumni Board

Alumni Office

405 Avery Hall
1172 Amsterdam Avenue
New York, New York 10027

Leah Cohen, Esther Turay, Elizah Laurenceau

/alumni/contact

Architecture Studio Lottery

/architecture-st…

Assistantships

/assistantships

Avery Library

300 Avery Hall
1172 Amsterdam Avenue
New York, NY 10027

http://library.c…

Avery Review

Joanna Joseph, Isabelle Kirkham-Lewitt

http://averyrevi…

Avery Shorts

Isabelle Kirkham-Lewitt, Joanna Joseph

http://www.avery…

B

Black Student Alliance at Columbia GSAPP

Building Science & Technology Waivers

/building-tech-w…

Bulletin Archive

/bulletin-archiv…

C

Career Services

300M Avery Hall

Karen Cover, Rebecca Andersen Polimeda, Douglas Woodward, Sarahgrace Godwin

/career-services…

Columbia Books on Architecture and the City

Isabelle Kirkham-Lewitt, Joanna Joseph, Meriam Soltan, Isabelle Tan

Commencement

Communications Office

415 Avery Hall

Steffen Boddeker, Lucy Krebsbach, Ilana Curtis

/communications-…

Conversations podcast

Counseling and Psychological Services

http://health.co…

Courses

Credentials Verification

/credentials-ver…

Credit Transfer

/credit-transfer…

Cross Registration

/cross-registrat…

D

Dean’s Letter

Dean’s Office

402 Avery Hall
1172 Amsterdam Avenue
New York, NY 10027

Janet Reyes, Sonya Marshall, Nicholas Roberts, Caio Major, Matthew Colunga

Development Office

404 Avery Hall

Leah Cohen, Esther Turay, Elizah Laurenceau

/development-off…

Directory of Classes (All Columbia University)

http://www.colum…

Disability Services

http://health.co…

Dodge Fitness Center

3030 Broadway Dodge

https://perec.co…

Dual Degree Program Requirements

/dual-degree-req…

E

End of Year Show

Events Office

415 Avery Hall

Steffen Boddeker, Lucy Krebsbach

External Funding Sources

/admissions/tuit…

F

Faculty Directory

Feedback

Finance Office

406 Avery Hall

Janet Reyes, Kristina Camaj, Amanda Seitz

/finance-adminis…

Fitch Colloquium

Sarahgrace Godwin, Jorge Otero-Pailos

Future Anterior Journal

Jorge Otero-Pailos, Sarahgrace Godwin

/future-anterior…

G

GSAPP Community Fellowship Program

/anti-racism-act…

GSAPP Emergency Fund

/gsapp-emergency…

GSAPPX+

Grades

Graduation

Graphics Project

/graphics-projec…

H

Honor System

Human Resources

Elizabeth Alicea, Amanda Seitz

/finance-human-r…

Hybrid Pedagogy Resources

/hybrid-pedagogy…

I

IT Helpdesk Ticket, GSAPP

https://bit.ly/2…

IT Office, GSAPP

Ben Goldie, Alvaro Gamboa, Christopher Hou, Roberto Marsach Jr., Nicholas Martucci, Diego Patino Toro, Hannette Un

IT, Columbia University (CUIT)

http://cuit.colu…

Identity

Incubator Prize

/research/gsapp-…

International Students and Scholars Office (ISSO)

http://www.colum…

J

Job Opportunities at Columbia

http://www.colum…

K

Kenneth Frampton Endowed Lecture Series

/frampton-lectur…

Kinne Prize

L

LatinGSAPP

Leave of Absence Policy

/leave-of-absenc…

M

Making Studio

Schermerhorn Extension Floor 1

Joshua Jordan, Yonah Elorza

https://www.arch…

N

News and Press Releases

Newsletter Sign Up

https://columbia…

Non-Discrimination Statement and Policy

/non-discriminat…

O

Onera Prize for Historic Preservation

Online Admissions Application

GSAPP Admissions 407 Avery Hall

https://apply.gs…

Output Shop

116 Avery Hall
1172 Amsterdam Avenue
New York, NY 10027

Carlito Bayne, Sherly Orilas

Ownership of Student Work Policy

/ownership-of-wo…

P

Paris Prize, Buell Center

/buell-paris-pri…

Paul S. Byard Memorial Lecture Series

/byard-lectures

Percival & Naomi Goodman Fellowship

/goodman-fellows…

Plagiarism Policy

/plagiarism-poli…

Policies & Resources

/policies-resour…

Press Releases

Publications Office

415 Avery Hall
1172 Amsterdam Avenue
New York, New York 10027

Isabelle Kirkham-Lewitt, Joanna Joseph, Meriam Soltan

Q

QSAPP

R

Registration

Registration: Add / Drop Form

https://docs.goo…

Room Reservations

/room-reservatio…

S

STEM Designation

Satisfactory Academic Progress

/satisfactory-ac…

Scholarships

/admissions/tuit…

Skill Trails

https://skilltra…

Student Affairs

400 Avery Hall

Danielle Smoller, Emily Dennis

/student-affairs…

Student Awards

/student-awards

Student Conduct

/student-conduct…

Student Council (All Programs)

/student-council…

Student Financial Services

http://sfs.colum…

Student Health Services at Columbia

http://health.co…

Student Organization Handbook

/books/catalog/5…

Student Organizations

/student-organiz…

Student Services Center

205 Kent Hall

https://ssc.colu…

Student Services Online (SSOL)

https://ssol.col…

Student Work Online

Studio Culture Policy

/architecture-st…

Studio Procedures

/studio-procedur…

Summer Workshops

/summer-workshop…

Support GSAPP

https://arch.giv…

T

Travel Guide

/finance-adminis…

U

URBAN Magazine

University Apartment Housing (UAH)

http://facilitie…

University Resources

/university-reso…

W

Website

Steffen Boddeker, Ilana Curtis

/website-colopho…

Close

This website uses cookies as well as similar tools and technologies to understand visitors' experiences. By continuing to use this website, you consent to Columbia University's usage of cookies and similar technologies, in accordance with the Columbia University Website Cookie Notice

Elizabeth M. Marcello

Tue, Oct 11, 2022 1:15pm

New York, LiPS (Lectures in Planning Series)

When Government is Opaque: Empire State Development and the Penn Station Redevelopment Project

Lecture by Elizabeth M. Marcello, a graduate of GSAPP’s PhD in urban planning program and a Senior Research Analyst at Reinvent Albany, nonpartisan, nonprofit organization that advocates for transparent and accountable New York State government. At Reinvent Albany, Elizabeth advocates for laws that curb business subsidies, improve open data and the Freedom of Information Law, and implement anti-corruption reforms. Her academic research focuses on city-state relations, economic development, and governance.

Transparency and accountability are basic tenets of democracy. Public planners extol the open manner in which plans are developed and implemented; the government provides information, the public is consulted, and plans change and adapt based on public input. This, of course, does not always happen. When carried out by public authorities, plans are not subject to the same disclosure and accountability rules as when carried out by typical governmental agencies. Public authorities are a type of special purpose government that can supplement routine government functions by building infrastructure, maintaining bridges, building stadiums and convention centers, managing public housing, and running mass transit systems. These entities were created during the Progressive Era to isolate planning from politics and allow planning expertise to flourish, but does their use help or hurt democratic planning efforts? Using the ongoing case of the New York Empire State Development Corporation’s Penn Station Redevelopment project in Manhattan, Marcello shows how public authorities operate outside of legislative politics and move projects quickly from concept to completion. Potential reforms are offered as solutions to the many challenges that public authorities pose to democratic planning efforts.